Trust the Evidence

Trust the Evidence

Studies that Misled the World - No Serious Adverse Events

How two of the most cited published trials of oseltamivir misled the world

Carl Heneghan's avatar
Tom Jefferson's avatar
Carl Heneghan and Tom Jefferson
Apr 28, 2025
∙ Paid

In 2010, we met at New College in Oxford to discuss the methods of our updated and amalgamated review of antivirals.

The news of our upcoming update to the Cochrane review was circulating, catching the attention of various media outlets eager for a story. In light of this interest, we approached Roche with a request: could they release the data from the Kaiser et al. review? Our goal was to verify the review's findings and provide an adequate response to Hayashi’s comments.

Share Trust the Evidence

Unfortunately, Roche did not provide the requested data. Instead, they later characterised the media’s early involvement as evidence of a conspiracy against them. This response was particularly frustrating for us, as our only intention was to gain access to the data to update our review.

The next drama came in 2009 when Tom’s phone rang, and a voice said, “Hello, Dr Jefferson, I am the person who wrote the Treanor and Nicholson trials.”

The Story of Influenza Antivirals: Part 4

The Story of Influenza Antivirals: Part 4

Tom Jefferson and Carl Heneghan
·
March 28, 2023
Read full story
User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Carl Heneghan.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Carl Heneghan · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture